Skip to main content
National News Desk
education

What should a university degree certify in the AI age?

The Hindu Education & CareerBy The Hindu Education & Career
18 Nov 2026
Original: English
AI Synopsis & Key Briefing

As AI transforms how students study and attempt exams, universities must find ways to assess what students understand and not merely what they submit

Key Highlights & Official Takeaways
  • ✓As AI transforms how students study and attempt exams, universities must find ways to assess what students understand and not merely what they submit
  • ✓Primary Authority: Official communique verified from The Hindu Education & Career.
  • ✓Civic Domain: Categorized under education public notices.
Comprehensive News & Policy Report

Artificial Intelligence is forcing India’s universities to confront a question they have avoided for years: what does it mean to know something? A student can now produce a convincing essay, analyse a business case, or write code with AI assistance.

However, the finished product does not necessarily reveal how much the student has understood. Against this background, experiments at IISER Pune, IIM Ahmedabad, IIM Bangalore, and the Indian School of Business offer an opportunity to reconsider how they assess students and what they expect them to learn.

Banning AI is no longer a realistic option,, as this will leave students unprepared for workplaces where these tools are increasingly used. IISER Pune, for instance, allows AI use by default. IIM Ahmedabad encourages AI-assisted preparation for classroom discussions.

IIM Bangalore has experimented with an exam in which students build chatbots to answer questions. ISB is exploring personalised AI tutors and simulations. These initiatives connect technology to specific learning objectives.

However, they also raise a fundamental question: can universities distinguish between using knowledge and acquiring it? Producing a correct answer and understanding why it is correct are different achievements. Research offers some evidence of this distinction.

A 2024 study by Bastani and colleagues involving high-school students in Turkey found that those using a standard chatbot performed better during practice but worse in a subsequent exam without AI assistance. A version designed to provide hints rather than direct answers largely avoided this decline.

One study cannot establish a general rule, but it points to an important risk. If assessment rewards only the finished product, universities may certify the appearance of competence rather than genuine understanding. This problem also exposes weaknesses in conventional education.

For decades, Indian higher education has relied heavily on memorisation, timed exams, and assignments that reward polished writing without necessarily establishing conceptual understanding. AI makes these shortcomings harder to ignore.

Universities must decide which abilities students should demonstrate independently and which they can develop with technological assistance. Skills that provide foundations for further learning, or that graduates must perform without assistance, should be tested independently.

Where the objective is to apply knowledge using available tools, AI can legitimately become part of the exercise. The distinction is relevant across disciplines. Language students need to construct sentences before relying on AI to improve their expression.

Statistics or Computer Science students must understand the reasoning behind a method before asking a chatbot to write the code. Literature students should develop their own interpretations before comparing them with AI-generated readings.

AI can extend learning in each case, but premature dependence can weaken the foundations necessary to use it effectively. AI could also make learning more demanding rather than simply more convenient. Instead of supplying answers, an AI tutor could ask progressively harder questions, challenge assumptions, and require students to defend their conclusions.

Science students could compare AI explanations with experimental evidence, while Humanities students could examine the historical and cultural assumptions that an AI interpretation overlooks. Students should also learn to verify references, identify fabricated information, and explain why they accept or reject AI-generated suggestions.

The educational objective should be independent judgement, not merely proficiency in writing prompts. Assessment methods must change accordingly. Students could submit a brief account of how they used AI, which suggestions they rejected, and how they verified their conclusions.

Oral exams and project discussions could establish whether they understand the submitted work. However, these methods have limitations. Oral exams are difficult to conduct on a large scale in Indian universities; examiners may apply inconsistent standards, and students can misrepresent their use of AI.

Selective vivas, supervised problem-solving, and clear assessment criteria could help, although they require additional faculty time and resources. Such changes cannot succeed through exam regulations alone. Faculty need training and institutional support to redesign courses.

Students must have fair access to reliable AI tools; otherwise, differences in affordability will widen educational inequalities. Universities must protect research confidentiality and personal data, establish clear limits on these technologies, and ensure that commercial platforms do not become unquestioned sources of knowledge.

UNESCO’s guidance on generative AI in education similarly emphasises human agency and educational and ethical scrutiny. Employers and professional accrediting bodies must also reconsider what they expect a university degree to certify.

The experiments at these institutions are, no doubt, promising but innovation alone does not establish educational value. Their success must be judged by whether students retain knowledge, understand concepts, and become better equipped to solve unfamiliar problems.

A university degree must certify more than the ability to operate technological tools. It must also demonstrate that graduates can question their outputs, evaluate evidence, and take responsibility for their conclusions.

AI may change how answers are produced, but universities must ensure that students still learn how to think. The writer is former professor and dean, Christ University, Bengaluru.

Actionable Steps for Aspirants & Citizens
  • •Aspirants and citizens are advised to monitor official notices and circulars issued by The Hindu Education & Career.
  • •Verify all prescribed eligibility criteria, cutoff dates, and authenticated document requirements prior to formal submissions.
  • •Track connected examination timetables, vacancy advisories, and administrative gazettes on SuchnaSetu.
Official Notice Specification
Issuing AuthorityThe Hindu Education & Career
Topic CategoryEDUCATION
JurisdictionAll India / National
Publication Date18 November 2026
Connected Government Jobs & Upcoming Exams
Active on SuchnaSetu
Official Source Attribution: The Hindu Education & Career
View Publisher Source Link

SuchnaSetu provides verified civic and public policy reports based on official notices. Primary publication and copyright remain with the respective government authority or publisher.