Why using chatbot as your lawyer is risky move
Why using chatbot as your lawyer is risky move - and ties up court system
- ✓Why using chatbot as your lawyer is risky move - and ties up court system
- ✓It contains 295 Australian cases in which a court or tribunal identified problematic use of AI in legal proceedings.
- ✓People might use chatbots built on large language models to help them with a legal matter in different ways: 1.
- ✓Advice about the law generally but also how it specifically applies to their own situation 2.
Sydney, In the Federal Court of Australia, applications by self-represented litigants, many using artificial intelligence to research and draft their claims, have skyrocketed. Why using chatbot as your lawyer is risky move - and ties up court systemThe Fair Work Commission, a federal tribunal, has already seen a jump in filings, many of them "AI slop".
These experiences are also reflected in our centre's global database of AI-related cases. It contains 295 Australian cases in which a court or tribunal identified problematic use of AI in legal proceedings. Examples include citing made-up case law, citing law that is real but irrelevant to the case, and using AI to write witness statements or submissions that aren't entirely accurate.
The database shows a huge increase in cases where these types of AI misuse has been mentioned over the past year, with self-represented litigants accounting for 81 per cent of Australian misuse cases. Access to courts is a fundamental part of access to justice.
But starting court proceedings without a viable or valid claim wastes time, causes stress and may have severe financial consequences for the person bringing the case. People might use chatbots built on large language models to help them with a legal matter in different ways: 1.
Advice about the law generally but also how it specifically applies to their own situation 2. Drafting of court documents to commence or defend a case 3. Drafting of court documents to support the case, such as submissions or statements about the facts .
While AI might usefully assist people to do all of these things, generative AI chatbots are much more sycophantic than humans. Lawyers have a duty to always act in their clients' best interests, which sometimes means challenging clients' views and delivering unpopular opinions.
There may also be errors in the material that they generate. For example, in Sadnan Khan v Aldi Pty Ltd, the Fair Work Commission took the unusual step of ordering costs of AUD 1,230 against a former Aldi employee who tried to sue for unfair dismissal.
The commission found Khan had relied on AI-generated arguments even though he should have realised his claim was doomed to fail. . To use AI successfully, people need to be able to check sources, verify information and ultimately explain the relevance of the legal arguments they are trying to make.
The higher the court, the riskier AI-use becomes The main impact of poor use of AI is twofold. First, most people are not successful, either because their legal argument doesn't work, or the facts don't support the argument, or both.
Two unpublished papers using data from US courts in civil matters show a similar pattern: large increases in court filings by self-represented people using AI but no apparent change to win rates, which remain low. Second, the recent Australian Federal Court data show unsuccessful claims are now working their way up the court food chain.
A high proportion of the increase in filings is made up of appeals from people who were unsuccessful in lower courts or tribunals. Litigating in higher courts, such as the Federal Court, is riskier. The "loser pays" rule of legal costs often applies .
This is different from lower-tier courts and tribunals, which are often "no cost" jurisdictions, meaning costs are not routinely ordered.
- •Aspirants and citizens are advised to monitor official notices and circulars issued by Hindustan Times World.
- •Verify all prescribed eligibility criteria, cutoff dates, and authenticated document requirements prior to formal submissions.
- •Track connected examination timetables, vacancy advisories, and administrative gazettes on SuchnaSetu.
| Issuing Authority | Hindustan Times World |
|---|---|
| Topic Category | TECHNOLOGY |
| Jurisdiction | All India / National |
| Publication Date | 19 November 2026 |